How to practice: This set collects only the Read, Then Speak question type from the real DET (Duolingo English Test) — DET Speaking questions. No grading, no timer — solve it yourself, then tap each question to reveal the answer or model response.
Q1
Explain whether you believe individuals have a moral duty to disobey laws they consider fundamentally unjust.
- When might breaking a law be justified?
- Can you give a historical example?
- What risks do civil dissenters face?
- How should society handle such disobedience?
Useful Expressions
From my perspective, when... · A prime example of this... · It's important to recognize that... · Ultimately, I tend to believe...
Show Model Response
From my perspective, when a legal framework directly conflicts with human dignity, individuals do have a moral obligation to resist. Historically speaking, legal systems haven't always aligned with basic ethical principles. A prime example of this would be the Civil Rights Movement, where peaceful protesters deliberately broke unjust segregation laws to highlight systemic inequality.
However, taking a stand through civil disobedience isn't easy. Dissenters often face severe consequences, like criminal penalties or public backlash. So, it shouldn't be done recklessly. It's important to recognize that breaking a law should always be a last resort after democratic channels fail. Ultimately, I tend to believe that while legal compliance is vital for social order, moral conscience must take precedence when laws violate fundamental rights.
However, taking a stand through civil disobedience isn't easy. Dissenters often face severe consequences, like criminal penalties or public backlash. So, it shouldn't be done recklessly. It's important to recognize that breaking a law should always be a last resort after democratic channels fail. Ultimately, I tend to believe that while legal compliance is vital for social order, moral conscience must take precedence when laws violate fundamental rights.
More “Read, Then Speak” sets at other levels · Browse the full DET question bank